What Verdica's 827 score means for Carey Dobbertin
Carey Dobbertin's composite score of 827 out of 850 places this Colorado-based accounting provider in the "excellent" band (800–850), indicating strong compliance standing across the measured dimensions. A score in this range reflects a provider with demonstrated adherence to regulatory standards, active licensing, and a clean or largely clean disciplinary record.
For a business owner or consumer evaluating an accounting provider, an 827 score signals low compliance risk. The provider has met or exceeded baseline expectations set by Colorado's state board and the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB). However, an 827—while excellent—is not a perfect 850, which means there are minor areas where performance differs from the highest tier. Readers should understand this as a strong endorsement with modest room for improvement, not a guarantee of perfect service or zero regulatory contact.
The absence of indexed customer reviews means Verdica's assessment is based purely on regulatory data, not client feedback. This is a limitation worth noting: compliance scores reflect adherence to legal and audit standards, not client satisfaction, responsiveness, or pricing fairness. A high compliance score does not predict whether a particular client will have a positive experience.
How the sub-scores break down
License & Credentials (830/850): This sub-score evaluates whether Dobbertin maintains active, current licensure and required professional credentials in Colorado. A score of 830 indicates the provider is properly registered and credentialed, with only minimal discrepancies or gaps in documentation. In the accounting field, this dimension flags providers who may be unlicensed, hold expired credentials, or lack required certifications. A score this high means that dimension is not a concern.
PCAOB Record (810/850): The PCAOB audits public company auditors and tracks the quality of their audit work through inspection findings. An 810 score suggests Dobbertin's prior PCAOB inspections have not flagged significant deficiencies in audit methodology, documentation, or quality controls. Lower scores in this dimension typically reflect findings of inadequate audit procedures, insufficient evidence gathering, or control weaknesses. At 810, this provider's audit work has been found generally sound, though the score is 20 points below perfect, indicating minor or resolved observations from inspection history.
Disciplinary (850/850): This perfect sub-score reflects an absence of serious disciplinary actions, sanctions, or complaints recorded in the Colorado state board registry. A maxed-out disciplinary score is straightforward: no major violations on file. Had Dobbertin faced suspensions, fines, or substantiated misconduct findings, this score would be substantially lower. This dimension is the strongest in the profile.
What regulators in CO track for accounting providers
Colorado's state board registration system requires accounting providers to maintain current licenses, disclose prior disciplinary history, and report continuing education compliance. The PCAOB, a federal regulator created under the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, periodically inspects firms that audit public companies or broker-dealers. PCAOB inspections examine whether auditors have sufficient quality controls, whether audit documentation meets standards, whether partners have adequate technical knowledge, and whether the firm complies with auditing standards and PCAOB rules. Deficiencies noted during PCAOB inspections can lower a provider's score; repeated or severe findings may trigger enforcement action. State boards also track complaints, malpractice allegations, and unlicensed practice. Verdica's scoring aggregates these data sources to create a compliance profile.
Bottom line
Carey Dobbertin scores in the excellent range and presents low compliance risk based on state and federal regulatory records. Before engaging this provider, verify that their service offerings align with your specific accounting needs, confirm references or reviews from prior clients, and clarify fee structures and service scope—none of which are reflected in a compliance score.