What Verdica's 827 score means for Carl Schroeder
Carl Schroeder's composite score of 827 out of 850 places this accounting provider in the "excellent" band (800–850). This score reflects strong performance across the dimensions Verdica tracks: professional licensing, Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) audit history, and disciplinary record.
For a business owner or consumer evaluating an accounting provider, an 827 score signals low compliance risk based on regulatory data. The provider has demonstrated adherence to professional standards and oversight requirements at a level well above the midpoint. However, the score is not perfect—27 points separate this provider from the maximum—which means there are minor findings or credential gaps worth understanding, even at this strong level.
The score should be interpreted as a starting point, not a final verdict. Regulatory compliance and credentials form one dimension of service quality; they do not measure responsiveness, pricing, communication style, or specialized expertise. A high score reduces the risk that you'll encounter serious licensing or audit problems, but it should be paired with your own due diligence: checking references, clarifying service scope, and verifying that the provider is a fit for your specific needs.
How the sub-scores break down
License & Credentials: 830 This sub-score reflects the status and scope of Carl Schroeder's professional licenses and certifications as tracked by New York state board registration. A score of 830 indicates that the provider holds valid credentials and meets baseline educational and renewal requirements. It does not indicate perfection—there may be minor credential gaps, lapses in continuing education documentation, or scope limitations that account for the 20-point deduction from a perfect score. In the accounting industry, license status is non-negotiable; providers without current licenses cannot legally offer certain services (such as auditing public companies). A score above 800 in this dimension suggests the provider is legally authorized and maintains good standing.
PCAOB Record: 810 The PCAOB is the federal regulator responsible for overseeing audits of public companies. This sub-score reflects Carl Schroeder's inspection history and any audit quality findings. A score of 810 indicates that PCAOB inspections have not uncovered serious deficiencies in audit methodology, documentation, or independence. The 40-point gap from perfect suggests the provider has had some audit findings—possibly minor control weaknesses, incomplete documentation, or sampling issues identified in PCAOB inspection reports. These findings are common in the industry and do not necessarily indicate fraud or gross incompetence; they reflect areas flagged for improvement. Providers with lower scores in this dimension may have failed to remediate findings quickly or may have a pattern of similar issues.
Disciplinary: 850 A perfect score here means Carl Schroeder has no disciplinary actions on record with state or federal regulators. This includes no complaints upheld by the New York state board, no SEC enforcement actions, and no settlements related to professional misconduct. This is a strong signal that the provider has not been found to have violated professional conduct rules or client trust obligations.
What regulators in NY track for accounting providers
New York's state board of accountancy maintains registration records that verify CPAs and accounting firms hold valid licenses, meet renewal requirements, and have no active disciplinary complaints. The PCAOB conducts triennial inspections of accounting firms that audit public companies, examining engagement files, quality control systems, and partner independence. Both regulators publish findings; Verdica indexes these to flag high-risk providers (those with unresolved findings, license lapses, or disciplinary histories) and credit those with clean records. Typical infractions that lower scores include failure to document audit work, inadequate partner rotations, and control deficiencies. Scores improve when providers remediate findings promptly and maintain consistent compliance over time.
Bottom line
Carl Schroeder's 827 score indicates a low-risk accounting provider with strong regulatory standing. Before engaging, confirm that the provider's specific services (tax, audit, bookkeeping) align with your needs and request client references.