What Verdica's 803 score means for Erin Castillo
Erin Castillo's composite score of 803 out of 850 places this accounting provider in the "excellent" range (800–850 band). This score reflects strong compliance standing across the dimensions that regulators and clients typically rely on to assess accounting provider quality and risk.
A score in the excellent band means the provider has demonstrated consistent adherence to licensing standards, audit quality measures, and disciplinary expectations as tracked by the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) and Colorado's state accounting board. For a business owner or audit committee considering Castillo's services, this score suggests a low-risk profile based on available regulatory data.
It's important to note that this score is constructed from regulatory records only—PCAOB audit findings and state registration data—and does not currently include independent customer reviews. A reader evaluating Castillo should treat this as a regulatory compliance baseline rather than a complete picture of service experience or client satisfaction.
How the sub-scores break down
License & Credentials (760/850): This sub-score reflects Castillo's standing with Colorado's state accounting board and professional licensure requirements. A score of 760 indicates solid compliance with registration, renewal, and credential standards. In the accounting industry, state licensing bodies verify that providers maintain active CPA licenses, meet continuing education requirements, and keep registration current. A score in this range—within the "strong" band (740–799)—means no major red flags in licensing history, though it is slightly lower than the other two sub-scores, which may reflect routine compliance points or administrative factors common to state registration.
PCAOB Record (810/850): This dimension captures Castillo's performance on PCAOB audit inspections and quality control assessments. A score of 810 sits comfortably in the excellent range and suggests that any PCAOB findings on file do not indicate systemic audit quality problems or pervasive control deficiencies. The PCAOB inspects registered accounting firms annually or triennially, evaluating the design and operating effectiveness of quality control systems, audit documentation, and compliance with auditing standards. A high score here typically means that audit inspection results did not reveal significant failures in judgment, substantial non-compliance, or repeated audit deficiencies.
Disciplinary (850/850): A perfect score on this dimension indicates no disciplinary actions, sanctions, or adverse findings on record from the PCAOB or Colorado's state board. In accounting regulation, disciplinary records track formal complaints, license suspensions, revocations, fines, or consent orders. A perfect score reflects a clean disciplinary history.
What regulators in CO track for accounting providers
Colorado's state accounting board and the PCAOB maintain overlapping but distinct oversight functions. The state board manages licensing, credential verification, and initial disciplinary matters. The PCAOB, a federally chartered nonprofit, inspects registered public accounting firms and enforces auditing standards for entities that audit public companies or broker-dealers.
Both regulators track several compliance metrics: adherence to Generally Accepted Auditing Standards (GAAS), quality of audit documentation, independence compliance, and proper communication with audit committees. Violations that lower scores include failure to maintain adequate audit working papers, inadequate testing of material account balances, violations of auditor independence rules, failure to update continuing education, or operating without active licensure.
Disciplinary actions—which directly impact the Disciplinary sub-score—result from formal investigations into alleged violations and may include public sanctions, license revocation, or mandatory corrective action plans. A provider with a history of such actions would see that dimension score decrease significantly.
Bottom line
Erin Castillo presents an excellent regulatory compliance profile based on PCAOB and state board data. Before engaging this provider, a business owner should verify that the scope and size of services align with Castillo's firm structure and past audit experience, and should seek independent client references or case studies to supplement the regulatory baseline.