What Verdica's 820 score means for Katherine Casebolt
Katherine Casebolt's composite score of 820 out of 850 places her in Verdica's "excellent" band (800–850). This score reflects strong performance across the three primary dimensions regulators track: professional licensing, PCAOB audit history, and disciplinary record. A score in this range indicates that an accounting provider has met or exceeded baseline compliance expectations and shows minimal red flags in the data sources Verdica indexes.
For someone considering working with Casebolt, an 820 score signals lower compliance risk relative to the broader population of accounting providers. It does not mean the provider is perfect or that no issues have ever arisen—rather, it means that available regulatory records show consistent adherence to professional standards. The score is based on verifiable public records (state board registration and PCAOB findings), not subjective opinion, so it provides a factual foundation for due diligence. Notably, no independent customer reviews are currently indexed for this entity, so the score reflects regulatory compliance only, not client experience or service quality.
How the sub-scores break down
License & Credentials (810/850): This sub-score reflects Katherine Casebolt's standing with Colorado's state board of accountancy and the currency and scope of her professional licenses. A score of 810 indicates solid licensure status with no major red flags in credential verification. In the accounting field, this dimension tracks whether a provider holds required CPA, CFA, or other designations; whether licenses are current and in good standing; and whether any license has been suspended, surrendered, or subject to restrictions. A high score here means regulatory bodies have no active concerns about the provider's right to practice.
PCAOB Record (810/850): The Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) is the federal regulator that oversees auditors of public company financial statements. This sub-score reflects Casebolt's history in PCAOB inspection findings, which focus on audit quality and compliance with professional standards. An 810 here indicates that any PCAOB records on file show acceptable audit practices, with no significant deficiencies or violations that would warrant a lower score. PCAOB audit findings can reveal issues like inadequate testing, weak internal controls, or failure to detect material misstatements. A strong PCAOB score suggests work product meets regulatory standards.
Disciplinary (850/850): This is a perfect sub-score, indicating no record of disciplinary action, complaints, or sanctions in available state or federal records. In accounting regulation, disciplinary records track actions taken by state boards, the PCAOB, the SEC, or the IRS against a provider—typically for violations like ethics breaches, fraud, negligence, or non-compliance with continuing education requirements. A perfect 850 means Verdica's data sources show no such actions against Katherine Casebolt.
What regulators in CO track for accounting providers
Colorado's Division of Registrations (which oversees accountants) and the federal PCAOB together create a compliance landscape that Verdica uses to assess provider reliability. State boards verify that providers hold valid CPA licenses, meet annual continuing professional education (CPE) requirements, and maintain ethical standards. They also investigate and log any complaints or disciplinary actions.
The PCAOB conducts triennial or cyclical inspections of accounting firms and auditors, examining audit files, quality control systems, and compliance with auditing standards. PCAOB findings become public record and include ratings of audit quality and any identified deficiencies. For individual practitioners like Casebolt, a clean PCAOB record is a strong indicator of audit competency.
Both regulators also maintain disciplinary databases accessible to the public. These record suspensions, revocations, fines, or consent orders resulting from violations. Verdica's scoring algorithm weights these records to flag providers with repeated issues or serious infractions.
Bottom line
Katherine Casebolt's 820 score places her in the excellent compliance tier, with strong credentials, clean PCAOB findings, and no disciplinary history on record. Before engaging her services, verify that her specific licenses align with your needs (e.g., audit, tax preparation, consulting) and consider requesting references, as regulatory compliance and client satisfaction are separate measures.